bs"d
Candle Lighting Light Candles
7:56 PM this Friday, 27 July 2018
Shabbat Ends 9:02 PM
Parashat
  Saturday, July 21, 2018 - 9 Av 5778
 
Share |
Guaranteed Pure Oil

"When the Hasmoneans overpowered and defeated the Greeks, they searched and found only one cruse of oil, which lay with the seal of the Kohen Gadol." (Shabbat 21b)

QUESTION:

What assurance did they have that the cruse was not touched by any of the Greek soldiers?


ANSWER:

This question is raised by Tosafot (ibid.), and answered, that it was buried in the ground, and thus the Greeks did not see it or know of its existence. A difficulty with this explanation is that there is no allusion to this fact in the Gemara. Moreover, if so, why was it necessary to have a seal on it?

Careful analysis of the terminology used in the Gemara, prompts one to ask:

  1. The Kohen Gadol was not in charge of making oil. Why would his seal be on the cruse?

  2. Grammatically, instead of saying "it lay" it should have said, "it was sealed."

From this we may deduce that when the Hasmoneans entered the Beit Hamikdash, their eyes beheld a fascinating phenomenon. They saw one cruse of oil, and it was laying together with the very valuable golden signet ring of the Kohen Gadol. They surmised, that undoubtedly, nobody had come into this area, because he definitely would have stolen the ring. Therefore, they confidently assumed that the cruse was not defiled by any of the Greeks, and fit for the Menorah kindling.

   
 

About us | Donate | Contact us | The Rebbe | News | Parsha | Magazine | Holidays
Questions & Answers | Audio

A Project of Beth Israel of Westport/Norwalk CT
40 King Street, Norwalk, CT 06851
Tel: 203.866.0534 Fax: 203.831.8969
Email: info@bethisraelct.org

Powered by ChabadNJ.org © 2010 All rights reserved.